I look at On Basilisk Station, the first Honor Harrington book by David Weber, where Honor takes command of the light cruiser Fearless, gets humiliated in war games, and is sent off to a backwater station where she starts cleaning up the corruption and stumbles into a plan by the People’s Republic of Haven.
I think it’s a really good, enjoyable read. Honor owes a lot to Hornblower but she’s a well developed character in her own right, and the space battle is great (I wanted more). My only real gripe is that it drags in places when Weber gets into the science, but anyone who likes space opera should have it on their bookshelf.
I mentioned in a previous post the Honor Harrington series of books by David Weber, but I don’t think I’ve ever actually spoken about them in any depth, so I thought I’d do so now. The first book in the Honorverse is On Basilisk Station, and it’s available for free from the Baen eBook Library, so it’s definitely worth a download if you haven’t already read it. Weber has written quite a few series and books now with strong female characters (take his Safehold series for example), but Honor is definitely one of his strongest and most well developed, and this is where it all starts.
The free download really is the best way in, because this is a long series, and it’s nice to be able to try the first book without spending anything to see whether Honor’s for you. The book’s more than twenty years old now and it holds up surprisingly well. The technology is all made up, so it doesn’t date the way near-future stuff does, and the things that drive the story (duty, loyalty, corruption and politicians making bad decisions a long way from the front line) don’t really go out of fashion. If you like your science fiction with ships, chains of command and a heroine who’d rather do the right thing than the easy one, you’re going to have a good time with it.
Honor Harrington and the Fearless
Honor Harrington takes command of a new ship, the light cruiser Fearless, and she’s thrilled about it, right up until she finds out what’s been done to it. The ship has been gutted of most of its normal offensive weapons and rebuilt as a test bed for a new weapon, a grav lance, based on the thoughts and insights of a group of armchair admirals who are sure they’ve found the future of naval warfare. It’s the kind of thing I’d expect to find in Old Man’s War or any decent bit of military science fiction, the people at the top making the calls and the people on the ship living with the consequences. And Honor, being Honor, just gets on with it and makes the best of what she’s been given.
Successful in its first war-game trial (and it really is a clever bit of tactics on Honor’s part), the Fearless is then humiliated by the rest of the fleet once they’ve worked out what it’s carrying and how to beat it. The experiment’s a failure as far as the brass are concerned, and somebody has to carry the blame for it, so the ship is sent in disgrace to Basilisk Station. It’s a low-status drudge assignment that mostly involves checking cargoes for contraband, the sort of posting you get when someone wants you out of sight for a while. Honor has her treecat Nimitz with her too, a six-limbed telepathic cat who rides on her shoulder and can read emotions, and I’ll admit he’s one of my favourite things about the whole series.
A backwater posting that isn’t
Arriving at Basilisk Station, Honor is left in charge by a malicious superior officer who’s quite happy to head off and leave her holding the bag, because he’s hoping she’ll fail. He’s an old enemy from her academy days and he’s exactly as unpleasant as you’d expect. But Honor believes in upholding the true values of the Manticoran naval tradition, and she manages to motivate her crew to follow her example, even though most of them are sulking about being sent to the back end of nowhere. Watching her turn a resentful crew into one that would follow her anywhere is half the fun of the book, and it’s the same thing that made the politics in the Foundation series so readable for me, people quietly doing the work while the big powers move around them.
Finding quick success in a part of space that had previously been significantly corrupt, Honor makes waves both at home and on Haven, because Haven had been counting on the sloppiness of the previous commander to make their eventual move on Medusa, the planet the station orbits, a success. But it’s not only the Havenites that Honor is causing problems for. Her honesty and integrity are impacting her own people as well, as she starts bringing fines against corrupt traders and merchants who’d got very used to nobody looking at their cargo. Unfortunately this doesn’t earn Honor a lot of friends! By the time things really start going wrong on Medusa she’s got very few people back home in her corner, and that makes what she does at the end even better.

Hornblower in space? Not quite
The biggest inspiration for this series, set far in the future, is surprisingly from the past. David Weber has (admittedly) taken some key elements and themes of his story from Horatio Hornblower, the initials are no accident either, and one long-time Hornblower fan goes as far as saying Honor knocked Hornblower off his perch for them. While this isn’t simply a case of Hornblower with boobs, some of the similarities are glaringly obvious: the navy, the duty, the officer who has to keep her feelings to herself in front of the crew and the politicians back home who don’t deserve the people they send out.
Honor isn’t just a clone of Hornblower, however. As I said, there are similarities, but she’s a well developed character in her own right, one that you can believe in and whose motivations and actions are clear. While Honor is presented as a very intelligent young woman, thanks to the anti-aging treatments available in the Honorverse she’s actually what we’d consider middle aged, so her command of a warship makes a lot more sense than it would otherwise. She’s got years of service behind her, she just doesn’t look it, and she’s got the kind of quiet confidence (and occasional self-doubt) that comes with that.
What makes her believable for me is that she isn’t perfect at everything. She’s brilliant on a bridge and in a fight, but she’s awkward with people outside of her job, she’s not great at politics, and she has a temper that she works very hard to keep a lid on, especially around the officer who left her at Basilisk. She cares about her crew to a fault, and it shows in the way she handles them, firm but fair, and in how much the losses hurt her when the fighting starts. You understand why her people end up so loyal to her, and that’s what turns this from a straight Hornblower homage into something that stands on its own two feet.
The detail, the drag and the battle
Weber provides a significant amount of detail about hyperspace, space battles, shielding, missiles, governments etc… one thing definitely not lacking in this book is the amount of detail! In fact, that’s probably the only major fault I’d have with it, it sometimes tends to drag as he expounds on the science and how it impacts everything from how fast a ship can accelerate to how a battle actually plays out. Not a major complaint, but one that should be noted, because if you’re the kind of reader who wants to get to the shooting, you’ll find yourself skimming a page or two now and then.
By contrast, one huge plus is that he doesn’t bore you with the details for the things that have no bearing on the story, the whole naming convention for example, Basilisk and Medusa. Many authors, especially those just starting out, would feel the need to explain everything, but I was glad to see that Weber didn’t feel this was necessary. So you get the detail where it matters (how the ships work and why a battle goes the way it does) and you’re left alone where it doesn’t, and I wish more writers made that call.
Overall it’s a really good and enjoyable read, and one that’ll keep you interested and occupied. The space battle (I would’ve liked more!) is really well written and described, and you feel every hit the Fearless takes. And while the stupidity of the politicians is perhaps a bit forced, it unfortunately makes way too much sense. Anyone who enjoys space opera will definitely want to have this on their bookshelf.
Did the slow science bits bother you, or is that level of detail exactly why you read Weber? Tell me in the comments.
4 comments
[…] you’re coming to Weber for the first time, I’d still point you at Honor Harrington and On Basilisk Station before this, mostly because it’s a leaner introduction to how he writes. But if the premise here […]
[…] appalling things to galleys, and Weber has a deserved reputation for that going all the way back to On Basilisk Station and the Honorverse. So the honest question going into Corisande was whether he could do the same […]
Going back to this one, it’s funny how much of the Honorverse is already here in the first book. Haven getting ready to expand, Manticore’s politicians squabbling while the navy does the work, Nimitz quietly judging everyone Honor meets. It reminds me a bit of Ender’s Game in the way the people in charge set up their best officer to fail and then can’t quite believe it when she doesn’t.
[…] else play a really long campaign. It’s a very different kind of David Weber book from On Basilisk Station, co-written with Steve White and built around whole fleets rather than one captain and her ship. […]